Earlier this year, the Ontario government introduced a critical change to the capital gains inclusion rate that will significantly impact the province’s real estate investors. Effective for capital gains realized on or after June 25, 2024, these new rules are both nuanced and impactful, particularly for those holding substantial assets. Let us unpack the details and implications, using the tried-and-true rigor that any self-respecting Canadian tax lawyer would bring to the table.
For those familiar with our tax code, you know that the capital gains inclusion rate has long hovered at 50%. But with the 2024 Budget, Ontario has shaken things up, introducing a tiered system for capital gains:
For Individuals: The first $250,000 of annual capital gains will retain the 50% inclusion rate. However, gains above this amount will face an increased inclusion rate of 66.67%.
For Corporations and Trusts: The inclusion rate has been raised from 50% to a flat 66.67% for all capital gains, regardless of amount.
From a practical perspective, this means that real estate investors, many of whom routinely achieve gains exceeding $250,000, are facing a more significant tax liability. For individual investors, this two-tiered system creates a potential tax planning opportunity, or a challenge, depending on your timing and strategic foresight. For corporations and trusts, however, it is a more straightforward increase across the board.
The Real-World Impact on Real Estate Investors
Ontario real estate, as many of you well know, is a sector where capital appreciation is often expected, and at times, it is explosive. Investors with properties in high-growth areas or those holding large portfolios may see gains of $500,000 or more in a single sale. Under the new rules, those investors would pay tax on the first $250,000 of gains at the 50% inclusion rate, and on the remaining $250,000 at 66.67%. The tax implications, especially on higher-tier gains, can be substantial.
Strategic Insights for Mitigating Tax Exposure
A change like this demands strategic planning. Let us explore a few practical tax strategies that Ontario’s real estate investors can consider to manage or mitigate the impact of these changes.
1. Timing of Sales: Stagger and Conquer
For those of you with large portfolios, staggering your sales to stay below the $250,000 threshold each year might be a smart play. Instead of realizing capital gains all at once, spacing out transactions across multiple years could allow you to take full advantage of the 50% inclusion rate on smaller gains annually. In a market like Ontario’s, where timing and location play an outsized role, this tactic could mean substantial tax savings.
2. The Principal Residence Exemption (PRE)
Never overlook the Principal Residence Exemption. For investors with multiple properties, one of the most powerful tax planning tools remains the ability to designate a property as your principal residence, which is typically exempt from capital gains tax on its sale. Consider alternating between properties to maximize this exemption if your living situation allows. And yes, the CRA takes a hard look at such moves, so stay within legal bounds - there is no aggressive gamesmanship here.
3. Capital Loss Planning: Offset to Optimize
If you have got underperforming assets or properties sitting in a loss position, now might be the time to realize those losses. These losses can offset gains realized in the same year or be carried forward to offset future gains at the 66.67% inclusion rate. Harvesting capital losses from other investments or real estate holdings can create valuable tax efficiency.
4. Corporations and Trusts: Re-evaluate Their Place in Your Strategy
For those of you using corporate structures or trusts to hold real estate, it is time to reassess. With all corporate and trust-held gains now facing the 66.67% rate, these structures no longer offer the same tax advantage on capital gains. While they may still provide benefits in terms of liability limitation, estate planning, and income-splitting, the tax efficiency might no longer outweigh the increased liability.
5. Access Equity through Refinancing without Triggering a Gain
If your goal is to access the equity from a property without incurring a tax event, refinancing could be a prudent option. Unlike a sale, refinancing does not trigger a capital gain, allowing you to utilize your asset’s value without facing immediate tax consequences. Given the higher inclusion rates, creative refinancing strategies are likely to become even more popular among savvy investors.
Long-Term Strategies for High Net-Worth Investors
For those of you with substantial portfolios and gains far above the $250,000 mark, long-term strategic planning is essential. Consider professional asset reallocation, estate freezes, and succession planning strategies. Complex structures may be warranted to minimize tax over time. While these are not simple, they are effective and worth exploring with your advisors, particularly in the face of an increased inclusion rate.
Final Thoughts
As we have seen, the 2024 Budget’s capital gains changes introduce a graduated system that creates both obstacles and opportunities for Ontario’s real estate investors. Those who adopt a proactive, informed approach will likely fare better than those who do not, given the higher tax implications now looming over the province’s most substantial gains.
Ontario’s new tax environment is not about eliminating gains but about managing and structuring them for optimal results. This is where precise planning comes into play. Work closely with a tax advisor and tax lawyer who understands both the technical nuances of the law and the strategic imperatives of real estate investing. By doing so, you will be well-positioned to preserve the value of your hard-earned gains, even in a shifting fiscal environment.
In tax law, as in real estate, knowledge is power, and a well-informed strategy can be the difference between a lucrative return and an outsized tax bill.
Want to get in touch with a tax or real estate lawyer?
Download the ALF One-Stop Client Portal App
Email us at reception@alfllp.ca
Call us at 905-629-2722
Comments